Postmates vs Doordash: Whom to drive for?

Best Promo code Postmates

Postmates vs Doordash: Which Is Better for Drivers? Detailed Comparison

When it comes to signing for one of deliveries companies, the choice can be the hardest: Postmates or Doordash. Read on for a closer at look at some of these differences.

Postmates vs Doordash: a complete comparison

Factors to consider before you sign up for Postmates or Doordash

When it comes to signing for one of deliveries companies, the choice can be the hardest: Postmates or Doordash. It's not simple; both offer a lot of great advantages (a job without many requirements, a part time or a full time job in which you are free to set your own hours) and they may seem basically the same other than brand. However, a closer look shows that there are some key differences. Read on for a closer at look at some of these differences to help you decide whether Postmates or Doordash is right for you.

Postmates or Doordash which is better to drive for?

Thanks to our experience and the data and information found in the Doordash Help Center website and Postmates Fleet Help Center we will explain everything you need to know about Postmates and Doordash driver/courier job. We will make a accurate comparison of the driver requirements, the vehicle requirements, the application process, from the sign up bonus to the background check to the Orientation.

At the end of this article you will have all the elements to make your choice and get a lucrative and satisfactory work experience and earn more.

Difference Between Doordash and Postmates

The first thing to understand is the difference between Postmates and Doordash

What is Doordash?

DoorDash is an on-demand restaurant delivery service. They connect people and restaurant through Doordash App.

what is doordash
what is postmates

What is Postmates?

Postmates is an on-demand "everything" delivery service. Postmates help customers get whatever they need, whenever they are through Postmates app. If you want to learn more you can read our article what is Postmates.

For a driver the big difference between Postmates and Doordash is that while with Doordash you will deliver only food, with Postmates you can also find yourself delivering flowers 💐.

With Doordash app and with Postmates app, corporate or catering orders can be made.

Now that this first important difference is clear, let's continue with our analysis.

Postmates vs Doordash Requirements: How to become a Postmates driver ('Postmate') or a Doordash driver ('Dasher')

Postmates vs Doordash Driver Requirements

Postmates driver requirements and Doordash driver requirements are really similar so we list them below. If you qualify for one you definitely qualify for the other too.

  • You must be 18 years of age or older (you must be 21 to deliver alcohol)
  • Own a smartphone (iPhone or Android) Your smartphone will be your main work tool because everything goes through the Postmates App (Postmates fleet App) or the Dasher App.
  • Driver’s license (even if you don't own a vehicle, you need a valid U.S. driver’s license to become a Postmate or a 'Dasher'').
  • Have a S.S.N for the Background Check

Winner: Tie

Postmates vs Doordash Vehicle Requirements

What makes the difference are the vehicle requirements. If you choose to work for Postmates or Doordash, unlike Lyft or Uber, your car will not have to pass a vehicle inspection . There are no limits in the type of vehicle that you can use to perform the deliveries. But while both Doordash and Postmates claim a freedom to use any type of vehicle you want, after careful analysis in the main markets, this is actually true only for Postmates. We made a case study in our article of Postmates vehicle requirements. Take a look, you will see clearly a map with all the cities where Postmates and Doordash authorize walkers or bikers... For the moment, know that Doordash authorizes only car deliveries in different markets where instead with Postmates you can also do motorcycle deliveries.

Here is a list of some major markets with their respective authorized vehicles:

Postmates Vehicle Requirements | List of Vehicle types for main cities where you can work for Postmates

Related Resources:

Doordash Vehicle Requirements | List of Vehicle types for main cities where you can work for Doordash

  • Los Angeles: Car, scooter or Bicycle* (*only available in Downtown Los Angeles and Westwood)
  • New York: Car or bike
  • Brooklyn: Car or bike
  • San Francisco: Car, scooter, motorcycle, and bicycle
  • Chicago: Car or bike
  • Miami: Car or Scooter
  • Orange County: Car
  • Phoenix: Car
  • Las Vegas: Car
  • San Diego: Car
  • Portland: Car
  • Nashville: Car
  • Charlotte: Car

Requirements to become a Postmates or Doordash driver: Our opinion

Now that you have looked at this list and know that nobody works for dreams but for money. It is important to know that Postmates allows you to switch the type of vehicle you use at any time you want. If you read our article how much do Postmates drivers make, we refer to the part of the hidden costs of a delivery driver. With Postmates you can choose, for example, to make your bike deliveries during weekends and save gas money.

Postmates is an eco-friendly company, it has developed an ebike and scooter rental program in different cities. Is ecology today a factor not to be taken into consideration? We really believe no.

Winner: Postmates

Postmates background check vs Doordash background check: Becoming a Postmates driver or a Doordash driver

It's a mandatory step for all rideshare and delivery company.

The Postmates background check and Doordash background check cover criminal background history and if you sign up to use a car or a motorcycle, they also check your Motor Vehicles Record.

Your driving record/MVR contains information about your driving history including:

  • Status of drivers license
  • Traffic accidents
  • Driving record points
  • Traffic law violations, convictions and fines
  • DUI public records
  • Whether your driver license is valid, suspended or cancelled

Postmates Background Criminal Check & Doordash Background Criminal Check

The criminal background check includes national and county-level databases and records. Background screening company gathers the information from many different sources. More precisely your report lists information will include details such as:

  • Violent Crimes
  • Sexual Offenses
  • Theft
  • Property Damage
  • Felonies
  • DUI

Postmates background check vs Doordash Background check: last words

The background check is the same for Postmates and Doordash. We have collected some experiences about it and some candidates have noticed a difference in the timing of the background check. Postmates and Doordash use different companies to run the background check ... This explains why sometimes one result comes before the other. Learn more on what to expect on the background check and tips to pass it in our complete article. If you want to learn more you can taka a loot at our complete guide on Postmates Background Check

Winner: Tie

Postmates sign up bonus vs Doordash sign up bonus: How to claim your sign up bonus

The drivers are the backbone of Postmates, Doordash or other ridehare companies like Lyft or Uber. All these companies have developed a referral program to encourage drivers to sign up for them. The driver application process is really easy and free for both companies, it will take you a few minutes. Both companies seem healthy. Which one pays their drivers better and has a company culture that would suit you? We would like to focus on two main aspects:

  1. The sign up bonus amount
  2. The number of required deliveries
  3. The Referral Code

1.The Sign up Bonus Amount

When it comes to work and earnings what is the first feature you are looking for? Certainly clarity. Postmates and Doordash following Uber's footprints have changed their sign up bonus formula and both offer guaranteed earnings. What does it mean? It means that you will receive a certain amount if you make a required number of deliveries. But how much is the sign up bonus? Clarity here is primordial. Postmates details the sign up bonus and the number of deliveries required for each city in their Fleet Market website. Doordash unfortunately does not do the same.

2.The Amount of required deliveries

The amount of sign up bonus and required deliveries changes from city to city and obviously depends on the need and discretion of Postmates or Doordash. After an exam we noticed a difference between Postmates and Doordash. Generally the number of deliveries requested by Postmates to claim your sign up bonus varies between 30 to 60 (deliveries must be made within the first 30 days). The number of deliveries that Doordash asks for to be able to receive the sign up bonus ranges between 120 and 150 to be made in the first 60 days.

3.The Referral Code

After signing up and becoming a Postmates or Doordash driver you will have your referral code. You can simply share your code with your friends or potential drivers you know. The more people use your referral code, the better chance of receiving bonuses. Doordash has specific rules about the spread of referral codes. They say a Dasher can refer a maximum of 15 drivers every year. If you try to spread your Doordash referral code via website or social media, your account will be closed with no prior notice or justification. Are the rules the same for everyone? Doordash seems to show little clarity and seems to authorize a limited number of people to spread Doordash referral via website.

Postmates Sign up Bonus vs Doordash Sign up bonus: Our opinion

Doordash and Postmates offer a sign up bonus. The number of deliveries required is higher for Doordash. This aspect should be taken into consideration especially if you need to have cash fast. The most saddening aspect is the unfair approach that Doordash has with the referral code and the fact that exceptions to the rules are applied only to a segment of people.

Winner: Postmates

Postmates vs Doordash: Orientation

doordash orientation

Orientation is a mandatory process to become a Dasher , you must schedule it at the time of sign up. During the Orientation you will receive some information about the Dasher App (the Doordash app for drivers), and the red card (the card you will use to pay). They will suggest you to buy the Doordash welcome kit (t-shirt + insulated bag). Postmates does not provide an orientation in its application process, it's simple. The welcome kit including the insulated bag + card will be sent to you directly and FREE of charge at home(be careful to write the right address when signing up).

Related: Postmates driver requirements

Postmates Pay vs Doordash Pay: review of Postmates and Doordash pay model

Postmates, Doordash, Lyft, Uber ... the possibilities are many, but which one is really the most lucrative? Who among Postmates and Doordash will allow you to boost your incomes? We offer you a review (updated on March, 2019) made by Indeed of the hourly pay of a Postmates and a Doordash driver. This review is clear. A Doordash driver earns an average of $18.88/hr and a Postmates driver $24.98/hr. In fact, Postmates allows you to earn more thanks to batching orders. Take a look at our dedicated article and you will find all the details on how much does a Postmates driver make

doordash delivery driver hourly salary
postmates delivery driver hourly salary

Postmates Guarantee Pay

Postmates has an incentives program for new and existing drivers. Postmates offers Pay Guarantee in many cities. In San Francisco, for example, you earn at least $ 300 if you make 30 deliveries. I'll let you do the calculation if you do 30 deliveries a day for 30 days ;) It's interesting, is not it?

postmates guarantee pay

Doordash Guarantee Amount

DoorDash will show you the guaranteed amount you'll earn for completing a delivery before you choose to accept or reject that order. The guaranteed amount is based on a variety of factors including the size of the order, whether you have to place the order in person, and the projected driving distance, traffic, parking, and wait time at the store.

Postmates Tips

Once you complete drop off the customer receives a push notification asking them to rate the order and tip. If you want to learn more, you can take a look at our detailed guide to Postmates Tipping. Basically, customers are not able to place new orders until they take action on rating and tipping in their app. The app calculates a recommended 20% tip based on the total price. However, customers are free to tip any amount they choose. You’ll get 100% of tips.

Doordash Tips

This is a controversial topic. Recently Doordash has been accused of not giving drivers the tips. This bad practice has influenced the behavior of Doordash users who have stopped giving tips to Doordash drivers, convinced that they would never receive them. Currently the Doordash policy tips is under review.

Postmates and Doordash Pay model review: Our Opinion

Perhaps you have recently heard of the scandal regarding the Doordash tips policy. If for both companies the goal is to help drivers to complete more deliveries in less time. Postmates also help Postmates drivers to earn more through batching orders.

Postmates vs Doordash: Postmates Fleet App vs Dasher App

We said it, your smartphone is your main work tool. Through it you can scheduling yourself for deliveries, receive and accept orders, check your earnings and you will be assisted by Postmates/Doordash support in case of need. Before going on with the comparison we clarify that Postmates as well as Doordash and the other rideshare companies, have two Apps, one for the users / customers and one for the drivers. Postmates App is the customer App, do not let yourself be misled. You can learn how to use Postmates Fleet App in our guide. Here is a comparison of the two Apps.

The two Apps are very simple to use, both have an integrated navigation system. It is not difficult to navigate the menu of the two apps and find what you need. Congratulations to the developers!

doordash app
postmates fleet app

Related: Postmates Fleet App | Comprehensive Guide

Postmates Fleet Support vs Dasher Support

Postmates Fleet Help Support

Postmates Fleet help website has an entire part where you can find useful links and answers to frequently asked questions (FAQ).

Postmates provides three types of support for their drivers. Support via request (for non-urgent questions) through the fleet help website. Online Support (through Postmates fleet app) If you are online and have a problem, this is the right way to contact Postmates You can also use Twitter @Postmates_Help

Doordash Dasher Support

As for Doordash, the dasher app does not provide an online support menu for its drivers. Doordash drivers can receive support by requesting them through the doordash website. Doordash also seems to be quite responsive and support customers and drivers via twitter @DoorDash_Help

Winner: Tie

Download and Resources

If you want you can download our presentation: Postmates vs Doordash.

Postmates vs Doordash: Last words

postmates vs doordash

In conclusion, if you read our article about Postmates ratings, you already know that Postmates officially ditched its classic 1-to-5-star rating system for a binary thumbs-up, thumbs-down rating system. Unlike Doordash drivers, Postmates Fleet drivers do not live in fear of low ratings from customers. The requirements to become a Postmates or Doordash drivers are really minimal, Postmates seems to be more flexible than Doordash in terms of vehicle requirements allowing and accepting deliveries made with scooters in all the markets. As for the application process, Postmates still wins the medal. In fact, orientation is not necessary to become 'Postmate'and Postmates will offer you the insulated bag. If the pay model and the incentives are similar for both companies, working for Postmates you can make more money thanks to the baching orders. There are good surprises and bad surprises, Postmates is really clear about sign up bonuses and required number of deliveries, we cannot say the same for Doordash. Finally, the rules apply to everyone. We really do not appreciate the attitude Doordash has about the referral codes.

We hope this article has helped you answer your questions and trivia. Supports and our community, share this article and like our Facebook Page. logo

Get Postmates referral code and sign up now

Set up your Postmates Account and start to earn money

Get Postmates Sign-up Bonus

This website is made with LOVE 💗 © 2019 | Terms of Service & Privacy Policy | Sitemap | This website is not operated by Postmates, Uber, Lyft.